Juristeca
Juristeca País
    [2025] EWHC 1430 (Comm)
    Commercial Court

    [2025] EWHC 1430 (Comm)

    Fecha: 11-Jun-2025

    Loss, Peril and Causation 102

    Loss, Peril and Causation 102

    Legal Issues as to Loss 102

    CTL Concept Incorporated? 104

    The test for ‘loss’ 105

    The length of deprivation 118

    What is meant by deprivation of possession? 119

    Determining whether there has been a loss 121

    Legal Issues as to Peril 121

    All Risks 121

    War Risks 123

    Legal Issues as to Causation 132

    Principles of Causation 132

    Concurrent Causes 133

    The ‘Ann Stathatos’ 135

    The Evidence Adduced 137

    Expert Evidence on Russian Politics, Public Policy and Economics 137

    Expert Evidence on Russian Civil Aviation 141

    Documentary and Factual Witness Evidence 146

    The Salient Facts 149

    Before the Invasion 149

    Actions of the Russian Government to 9 March 2022 150

    PD 100, GR 311 and GR 312 158

    After GR 311 167

    The position of the Airlines 168

    Efforts at recovery 190

    Analysis and Conclusions 192

    Were the Aircraft lost and if so when? 192

    Which Peril(s) was or were Operating? 195

    What was the Operative Cause of the Loss? 195

    Notices to review and ‘grip of the peril’ 198

    Genesis 208

    Sanctions 213

    US Sanctions 214

    EU Sanctions 215

    • Heading
    • Introduction 7
    • The Issues 52 Contingent or Possessed Cover? 53
    • Loss, Peril and Causation 102
    • Chubb’s Russian Insurance Settlement Defences 219 Quantum 220
    • Overall Conclusions 230
    • The LP Policies and Claims
    • The Airlines
    • The Leases
    • Summary of Key Events
    • Summary of Insurance Settlements
    • The Issues
    • Contingent or Possessed Cover?
    • AerCap
    • DAE/Falcon
    • Merx
    • Genesis
    • Loss, Peril and Causation
    • Legal Issues as to Loss
    • Legal Issues as to Peril
    • Legal Issues as to Causation
    • The Evidence Adduced
    • The Salient Facts
    • Analysis and Conclusions
    • Notices to review and ‘grip of the peril’
    • Genesis
    • Sanctions
    • US Sanctions
    • EU Sanctions
    • Chubb’s Russian Insurance Settlement Defences
    • Quantum
    • ‘Recoveries’
    • VIM Airlines Thrust Reverser
    • DAE/Falcon claim for costs and expenses
    • Does the US$ 300 million aggregate limit apply to AerCap’s claim under the War and Allied Perils cover?
    • Conclusions

    Otros enlaces de interés:

    Jurisprudencia clasificada por bienes e inmuebles Jurisprudencia clasificada por contravención de las normas jurídicas Jurisprudencia clasificada por derechos de la unión europea Jurisprudencia clasificada por derechos fundamentales Jurisprudencia clasificada por materias del derecho Jurisprudencia clasificada por profesiones Jurisprudencia clasificada por sector agrario Jurisprudencia clasificada por sectores de la sociedad

    Síguenos en

    Políticas de eliminación | Políticas de privacidad

    © 2026 Juristeca