![[2024] UKUT 345 (AAC)](https://backend.juristeca.com/files/emisores/logo_3a2BKne.png){kind=logo}
the reason for imposing the sanction; and information on appeals which may be made under regulation 87
the reason for imposing the sanction; and
information on appeals which may be made under regulation 87.
A sanctions notice containing cancellation, reduction, suspension or withdrawal must include the date on which the sanction has effect.
A sanctions notice containing reduction must include—
the total amount of the reduction;
how the reduction has been calculated; and
the revised amount due under the energy plan.
A sanctions notice containing a financial penalty must include—
the amount of the penalty;
the period within which payment must be made;
how payment may be made;
details of the early payment discounts; and
the consequences of non-payment.
A sanctions notice containing suspension must include the date on which the suspension ceases to have effect.
Proportionality requirement
Any sanction imposed under this chapter must be proportionate to the breach in relation to which it is imposed
- Heading
- The decision of the Upper Tribunal is to allow GDFC Assets Limited’s appeal
- The statutory scheme
- A notice under these Regulations— must be in writing; and
- The improvement-specific instalments must not exceed the improvement-specific first year savings The improvement-specific payment period must not exceed the improvement-specific savings period
- Improvement-specific instalments – exceptions to fixed amount
- Guarantees to be given by green deal providers
- The guarantee must include the requirements set out in Schedule 3 (guarantees) Condition as to other matters – confirmation from bill payer and owners
- the relevant first bill payer; or subject to paragraph, the relevant subsequent bill payer; and
- A must pay instalments under the plan for such time as A is the bill payer, and the other terms of the plan which bind a bill payer will bind A
- Sanctions for breaches of the relevant requirements by green deal providers
- withdrawal
- the following may be imposed—
- that the Secretary of State intends to impose the sanction
- details of the early payment discounts
- the reason for imposing the sanction; and information on appeals which may be made under regulation 87
- Appeal to First Tier Tribunal
- The Tribunal may suspend a decision pending determination of the appeal The Tribunal may—
- Relevant factual background
- The decisions of the First-tier Tribunal
- Preliminary decision
- Substantive decision
- I will return, as necessary, to where aspects of this summary were unpacked by the FTT The FTT’s grant of permission to appeal
- The grounds of appeal
- Discussion and conclusion
- Grounds 2-4 – legal effect of non-compliance with regulation 30(3)(c) and whether written or oral notification is required by that regulation
- Nor does regulation 30(3)(c) containing a condition sit oddly with, or indeed lie outwith ( ultra vires ), the enabling powers of the parent Act under which it was made. Section 1(3) (b) of the Energy
- Grounds 5 and 6 – proportionality and approach to sanction
- Ground 7 – proportionality and sanction if not a green deal plan
- Conclusions