Claim No: CR-2024-004856 - [2025] EWHC 2304 (Ch)
Fecha: 10-Sep-2025
The ordinary shareholders’ Article 4 rights
The ordinary shareholders’ Article 4 rights
Article 1.1 of Koza Ltd’s articles of association makes applicable the Model Articles contained in Schedule 1 to the Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008 (the “Model Articles”).
Article 3 of the Model Articles provides that:
“the directors are responsible for the management of the company’s business”.
However, article 4 of those Model Articles (“Article 4”) provides (at article 4(1) that:
“The shareholders may, by special resolution, direct the directors to take, or refrain from taking, specified action”.
It may be seen that the combination of these provisions creates fertile ground for a stand-off between the ordinary shareholder of Koza (Koza Altin) and its sole director, particularly if, as has been the case up to now, the sole director (Mr Ipek) does not recognise the authority of the directors of Koza Altin to give him directions.
- Heading
- Introduction This hearing is dealing with an application (the “ Application ”) made by the Petitioner, Koza Altin İşletmeleri A.Ş. (“ Koza Altin ”), for summary judgment on (or alternatively strike out of the defe
- BACKGROUND Parties
- The confiscation of shares in Koza Altin
- The A ordinary share
- The ordinary shareholders’ Article 4 rights
- The 2016 and 2021 Proceedings
- The Interim Regime
- Disputes over the business of Koza Ltd
- SUMMARY OF KOZA ALTIN’S GROUNDS FOR WINDING UP
- LEGAL PRINCIPLES: SUMMARY JUDGMENT
- LEGAL PRINCIPLES: JUST AND EQUITABLE WINDING-UP
- ARE THERE GROUNDS FOR JUST AND EQUITABLE WINDING-UP?
- IS KOZA ALTIN THE 100% ECONOMIC OWNER?
- The dividend yield basis
- The share of net asset basis
- The value of the right to extract value
- Nuisance value
- My conclusions on the report
- DOES KOZA ALTIN HAVE NO CONTROL? The position up to the hearing
- The position following the undertaking given in the course of the hearing
- UNREASONABLE REFUSAL OF AN ALTERNATIVE
- COLLATERAL PURPOSE
- UNCLEAN HANDS
- STRIKE-OUT APPLICATIONS
- Conclusions