Issue (iv): Excluding the pre-existing relationship from consideration
Issue (iv): Excluding the pre-existing relationship from consideration
This issue is raised by ground 5 of the grounds of appeal. That is expressed as follows:
“The Learned Judge was wrong to exclude from consideration of the construction of the SHA (and thus from the concept of remediability) the pre-existing relationship between the parties, and in particular (a) [Mr Kulkarni] and (b) Mr David Lewis, the shadow director and ultimate beneficial owner of [Gwent], and Mrs Jayne Lewis, the director.”
- Heading
- Section 1
- Early history
- The SHA
- Subsequent history
- The issues
- Clause 7.1(d)
- The Judgment
- Mr Kulkarni’s case
- Discussion
- The Judgment
- Mr Kulkarni’s case
- Authorities
- Discussion
- Legal principles
- Mr Kulkarni’s case
- The Judgment
- Discussion
- Issue (iv): Excluding the pre-existing relationship from consideration
- Mr Kulkarni’s case
- The Judgment
- Discussion
- The Judgment
- Mr Kulkarni’s case
- Authorities
- Legal principles
- Discussion
- Conclusions
![CA-2024-001924 - [2025] EWCA Civ 1206](https://backend.juristeca.com/files/emisores/logo_Sjvxvlx.png)