HER HONOUR JUDGE MADELEINE REARDON :
Introduction1.This judgment is delivered at the conclusion of a fact-finding hearing listed to determine allegations of non-accidental injury to a young baby, S, born in March 2022. S’s older sibling, T, is also the subject of these proceedings. He is aged 3. 2.The local authority is LB Havering, represented by Richard Little. 3.S’s mother is represented by Bibi Badejo and his father by Rachael James. S and T are represented by Lucy Cheetham, through their children’s guardian, Kristin McKenzie.4.The hearing took place over five days and was attended, save that the medical experts gave evidence remotely and the children’s guardian, who has relocated abroad since this case commenced, also attended remotely. 5.I am grateful to all the advocates for the enormous assistance they have given me through their preparation and presentation of this difficult case.
- HER HONOUR JUDGE MADELEINE REARDON :
- Background
- The findings sought and the positions of the parties
- The law
- The evidence
- The medical evidence
- The parents’ evidence
- The family witnesses
- Analysis of the evidence
- The timeline: S’s birth to his admission to hospital on 23 April 2022
- Inherent probabilities
- An accident involving T
- Co-sleeping
- The evidence for and against a non-accidental injury
- My findings: the causation of S’s injuries
- The allegation of neglect
- Summary of outcome
