His Honour Judge Keyser QC
sitting as a Judge of the High Court
Between :
MARTIN BOWDERY Q.C. (instructed by Milners of Crown House, 85-89 Great George Street, Leeds, LS1 3BR) for the ClaimantsPETER FRASER Q.C. (instructed by Simmons & Simmons LLP, of City Point, One Ropemaker Street, London, EC2Y 9SS) for the DefendantHearing dates: 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th, 12th and 13th March and 2nd April 2012
- His Honour Judge Keyser QC
- H.H. Judge Keyser Q.C.:
- Warranties
- LAD’s
- Contract Documents
- Associated Architects
- Shire Consulting
- Some law
- TTPM’s duties and alleged failures
- Expert Evidence
- Dr Aldridge’s evidence
- Mr Hinchliffe’s evidence
- The Trust’s submissions on breach of duty
- TTPM’s submissions on breach of duty
- Breach of duty: discussion and conclusions
- Loss of a chance
- What would the Trust have done if appropriately advised?
- What would Kier have done?
- Would a contract have improved the Trust’s position?
- Would the Trust have availed itself of its improved position?
- Conclusion on causation
- (i) What were the chances of Kier signing the contract?
- (ii) How would the Trust have benefited from a signed contract?
- The claim for an extension of time
- (iii) Does TTPM have the benefit of an effective limitation clause?