![[2025] UKUT 371 (LC)](https://backend.juristeca.com/files/emisores/logo_lnJS4Uj.png){kind=logo}
The issues
The issues
The two issues for which the FTT gave permission were:
Whether the Estate, as defined in the lease, consists only of The Points, or includes the whole of the area designated by the Council as the Gascoyne Estate.
Whether Mr Williams is obliged to contribute to the cost of heating and hot water to other flats.
This formulation of the issues is less precise than it might be. As will become apparent, framing the first issue in the way the FTT did masks some of its complexities. Additionally, the issue in relation to heating is not about the cost of heating and hot water but rather is about the cost of work to heating installations in individual flats. As far as I am aware, Mr Williams has not been asked to contribute to the cost of heating other flats and he does not challenge his liability to contribute to the cost of maintaining the boilers and pipework which comprise the communal heating system serving The Points.