The SSHD’s application for permission to appeal, and if granted, to appeal the refusal of joinder as a party and to appeal the grant of the injunction
The SSHD’s application for permission to appeal, and if granted, to appeal the refusal of joinder as a party and to appeal the grant of the injunction.
Status on the appeal
The SSHD seeks permission to appeal to this court against the judge’s refusal to join her as a party to the injunction application and permission to appeal, as an intervener, against the grant of the injunction itself.
Although the SSHD was refused party status in the substantive proceedings before the judge, the definition of “appellant” in CPR rule 52.1(3)(d) is wide enough (“a person who brings or seeks to bring an appeal”) to include a non-party to the proceedings at first instance: see R (George Wimpey UK Ltd) v Tewkesbury BC [2008] EWCA Civ 12; [2008] 1 W.L.R. 1649, CA. Mr Green, while resisting the grant of permission to appeal to the SSHD on either the joinder issue or the merits, rightly did not suggest that we should refuse to allow Mr Browneven to make the applications.
- Heading
- Lord Justice Bean, Lady Justice Nicola Davies, Lord Justice Cobb
- Factual background
- Events since April 2025
- Legal proceedings
- The proposed intervention of the SSHD
- The judgment of Eyre J
- The SSHD’s application for permission to appeal, and if granted, to appeal the refusal of joinder as a party and to appeal the grant of the injunction
- Statutory duty of the SSHD
- Engagement of the SSHD with this application
- Judgment refusing permission to intervene
- CPR Part 19
- SSHD’s Grounds of Appeal
- The arguments
- Discussion
- Approach to appeals in interim injunction cases
- The deliberate breach issue and the judge’s approach to planning law issues
- Submissions for the SSHD
- The Council’s response
- The deliberate breach issue
- The stop notice issue
- The incentivisation of protest
- The wider picture
- The status quo
- Delay
- Conclusions
![[2025] EWCA Civ 1134](https://backend.juristeca.com/files/emisores/logo_Sjvxvlx.png)