KB-2025-000232 - [2025] EWHC 1784 (KB)
Fecha: 15-Jul-2025
The Defendant’s first two statements
The Defendant’s first two statements
The Defendant filed a witness statement headed “Meanings Witness Statement” dated 3 April 2025. Again, the document was wider in scope than the Preliminary Issues. The document included a transcript of the section of the YouTube video from 10.55 – 15.04 minutes into the broadcast, indicating by the colour of the font when Ms Miller was speaking and when her co-presenter was speaking. She stated she made no mention of the Claimant’s full name and that only “Chris” was used in the video. Ms Miller reiterated that she had not written the England Athletics emails, nor procured anyone to send them.
Pursuant to Master Davison’s direction for the exchange of witness statements, the Defendant also filed a document dated 3 May 2025 headed “Defence Witness Statement”, in this she again denied that she had written or procured the emails sent to England Athletics. She also repeated the points she had made in her earlier document as to whether the Claimant was identified in the YouTube video.
- Heading
- Section 1
- The background
- The pleaded claim in libel
- The litigation
- The “Claimant’s case for Trial of Preliminary Issues” document
- The Defendant’s first two statements
- The unredacted England Athletics emails
- Further Orders and the Defendant’s 26 June 2025 witness statement
- The Defendant’s evidence
- The legal framework
- Publication
- Defamatory meaning
- Reference to the claimant
- The Claimant’s submissions
- The England Athletics emails
- The Defendant’s submissions
- The England Athletics emails
- Analysis and conclusions; the YouTube video
- Merits of the Claimant’s case
- Meaning of the words complained of
- The England Athletics emails
- Natural and ordinary meaning
- Conclusions