Analysis of issues
73.This Court is in a similar position as HHJ Bellamy was in ABCDE. I do not have a reliable assessment that determines how I should approach the effect of separating the children in such a way that will deny them the option of sibling contact in the short and long term. Judge Bellamy had the time available to the children to order a psychological assessment. Whilst I do not have the option of extending the timetable, I would, in any event be slow to do so even if time were on my side. I am not being asked to consider the consequences of sibling contact orders that will extend beyond adoption; it would be premature to do so at this stage.74.Acknowledging from the research evidence referred to above that the consequences of contact post adoption, especially in the case of a large sibling group, require careful consideration at the point of adoption, the best I can do is to make an order requiring that contact continue during the placement process up to the point that one of the children is the subject of an application for an adoption order. This will ensure the local authority does not reduce the sibling contact during the placement process for any of the children. It will also alert any prospective adopters as to the potential for an order to be made under s51A. I am told that any order for contact will limit the pool of prospective adopters. I accept this is probably the case.
- The applications before the Court
- The parties’ positions
- The key issue: sibling separation
- ABCDE
- The background: the children’s lived experience
- The Law
- F (A Child : Placement Order: Proportionality
- The Public Law Working Group
- Re B-S
- Re H-W (Children)
- Re D (A Child Placement Order)
- Children and Adoption Act 2002
- The Adoption Agencies Regulations 2005
- Discussion as to the issues surrounding the effect of sibling separation
- Siblings, contact and the law: an overlooked relationship?
- Together or Apart? Assessing Siblings for Permanent Placement (BAAF, 2001, 2008)
- Beyond Together or Apart: Planning For, Assessing and Placing Sibling Groups (Coram BAAF, 2021)
- Beyond Together or Apart: Planning for, assessing and placing sibling groups 2021, a Coram Baaf Good Practice Guide
- Safe Contact: Children in Permanent Placement and Their Birth Relatives
- Section 26 ACA 2002: contact orders during placement
- Adoption and Children Act 2002
- Social media
- The Mother and F1
- The options for the children
- All children placed for and successfully adopted
- Placements being divided between foster placements and adoptive placements
- All children in foster care:
- All children to be returned home:
- The Children: pen portraits
- Siblings together and apart assessments
- The Children’s Guardian: Miss Madelaine Jones
- Strengthening Families: improving stability for adopted children 2021.
- Introducing Social Science Evidence in Family Court Decision-Making and Adjudication: Evidence from England and Wales.
- The possible adoption pathway for the children. Tracey Barton (Adoption Manager)
- Analysis of issues
- Options and Re B-S analysis
- Welfare checklist factors
- Conclusion
