HT-2022-000311 & HT-2022-000254 - [2024] EWHC 3179 (TCC)
Fecha: 11-Dic-2024
Heading

Royal Courts of Justice, Rolls Building
Fetter Lane, London, EC4A 1NL
Before :
MRS JUSTICE JEFFORD
Between :
(1) 381 SOUTHWARK PARK ROAD RTM COMPANY LIMITED (2) SOPHIA ELIZABETH SMITH (3) ARMAND JUNIOR FRANCOIS SABLON (4) PIZARRAS Y BALDOSAS SA (5) LAURA JANE MACKIE (6) CHARLES WILLIAM GEORGE FRY and EDWARD CHRISTOPHER MURRAY FRY (7) GLORIA NOK TUNG CHAN (8) PROPERTIES (RESIDENTIAL 2) LIMITED (9) SALIM LALANI and ROZMIN LALANI (10) KAMALA NADIR KYZY BUCHHOLZ (11) LUKE EDWARD PRICE | Claimants |
- and – | |
(1) CLICK ST ANDREWS LIMITED (in Liquidation) (2) CLICK GROUP HOLDINGS LIMITED | Defendants |
Mr Michael Levenstein (instructed by Adam Benedict Limited) for the Claimants
Mr Aaron Emmett (acting in person) for the Defendants
Hearing dates: 20 to 22 February; 27 to 29 February; 5 March 2024
Approved Judgment
This judgment was handed down remotely at 10.30am on Wednesday 11th December 2024 by circulation to the parties or their representatives by e-mail and by release to the National Archives.
.............................
MRS JUSTICE JEFFORD
Mrs Justice Jefford:
- Heading
- The parties
- The claimants’ case in summary
- Procedural matters and representation
- Amended Particulars of Claim
- The Agreement for Sale
- The purported rescission of the FPA and RTM’s claim
- The no loss defence
- The position of the leaseholders and the leaseholders’ claims
- The leases
- Insurance
- Breach of statutory duty
- Negligence
- Nuisance
- The rainwater ingress
- Breaches
- Click St Andrews’ position
- Discussion
- Other defects and expert evidence
- The Rivett reports
- Mr Ferguson
- Miscellaneous defects
- Mr Ebbatson
- Remedial works
- Quantum
- Flat 1
- Flat 5
- Flat 6
- Flat 7
- Flat 8
- Flat 9
- Flat 10
- Flat 11
- Flat 12
- Flat 13
- Mitigation
- Conclusions