QB-2022-001397 - [2025] EWHC 2193 (KB)
Fecha: 22-Ago-2025
Mr Clarke’s live witnesses
Mr Clarke’s live witnesses
I heard live evidence called on behalf of the Claimant from nine witnesses (including from Mr Clarke himself), over the course of six days from 10 March to 17 March 2025 (days 4-9).
Mr Clarke made two trial witness statements. He gave evidence for more than three and a half days (days 4-7), including three days of cross-examination. As the explicit photographs of ‘Ivy’ had not been provided to the Guardian or disclosed when Mr Clarke first gave evidence, he chose to be re-called to give evidence on the topic. He was re-called on day 18, a week after inspection of the photographs was given.
David Wade (Footnote: 2) gave evidence in person on the afternoon of day 7. Iris Clarke, the Claimant’s wife, gave evidence in person the same afternoon. Louise Urwin (whose professional name is Louise Dylan) gave evidence in person on the morning of day 8. Andrew Loveday gave evidence via a video link on the morning of day 8. Joshua Myers, Philip Dore, Jared Schwartz and Cedric St Clair each gave evidence via video link on day 9.
Each of these witnesses had made a single statement on which they were cross-examined. I address the evidence of each of the Claimant’s witnesses who gave live evidence in the context of the allegations to which their evidence is relevant.
- Heading
- Index
- Post-trial submissions regarding the meaning of the meanings
- Pleadings, meaning trial and listing of the trial
- Disclosure and Inspection
- Exchange of witness statements
- Pre-trial review
- Mr Clarke’s application to strike out the defence
- The Guardian’s application to summons Arnold Oceng
- The Guardian’s application to call ‘Ivy’
- Mr Clarke’s application to re-amend the Amended Reply
- Mr Clarke’s application to rely on his second witness statement
- The Guardian’s application for evidence to be ruled inadmissible
- Mr Clarke’s Transcripts Application
- Mr Clarke’s Redactions Application
- Mr Clarke’s withdrawn applications to serve witness summaries and summonses
- Mr Clarke’s application for special measures
- The Guardian’s application to call ‘Anita’
- Applications on the disclosure of explicit photographs of ‘Ivy’
- The Guardian’s application for Mr Moore to give evidence by video link
- Post-hearing submissions
- Mr Clarke’s live witnesses
- Arnold Oceng
- Hearsay statements from the Claimant’s witnesses
- The Guardian’s live witnesses: truth defence
- The Guardian’s hearsay witnesses: truth defence
- The Guardian’s live witnesses: public interest defence
- Overview
- The initial group of seven
- The Guardian’s team
- The sources for the first article
- Alleged involvement of Adam Deacon
- The Hostility Issue
- The Verification Issue
- The Contamination Issue
- The Reply Issue
- The Deletion Issue
- Conclusions