The Side Letter
The Side Letter
The Side Letter was executed on 29 January 2010, approximately eighteen months after the execution of the Agreements.
By the execution of the Side Letter, CPW and BBUK agreed that:
the purpose of the letter agreement was to clarify the intentions of the parties to the MSA;
paragraph 1 specified that that intention was that BBUK should be entitled to the majority of the benefits arising from the operations of the Businesses and that this was reflected in the management charge. At the same time, CPW should not incur an accounting loss for any financial year as a result of fulfilling its obligations under the MSA – except where actions or agreements regarding other operations of CPW had resulted in such a loss arising in the Businesses or material one–off items during the period had significantly reduced the profitability of the Businesses – and that, should CPW incur such a loss, the parties reserved the right to renegotiate the management charge accordingly;
paragraph 2 provided that, in the event that CPW became insolvent, BBUK would assume the management of the Businesses and fulfil all of the Businesses’ obligations “including but not limited to payroll and rental costs”;
paragraph 3 provided that CPW would request BBUK’s prior approval regarding any major strategic decisions in relation to the Businesses, including, but not limited to, cessation of the Businesses and significant changes in the operations of the Businesses; and
paragraph 4 provided that, in accordance with the clause in the MSA which provided for the management charge to be adjusted by mutual agreement and paragraph 1 of the letter agreement, the parties agreed to vary the management charge with effect from 1 July 2008 to 91.19% of all revenue generated by the Business. For this purpose “revenue” was defined as “the difference between all profits generated by the Businesses less all costs incurred by CPW in running the Businesses”.
- Heading
- Introduction
- Key parties
- Acquisition of the Businesses
- The SPA and the MSA
- The Degrouping
- Procedural background
- the agreed issues
- the agreements
- The SPA
- The MSA
- The Side Letter
- Initial observations on the Agreements and the Side Letter
- other documents
- The Prior SPAs
- The Property Services Agreement
- The Brand Licence
- The Accounts
- The Invoice
- “ About the matter we have finished checking
- “Partial closure notice (PCN)
- The issues – a summary
- Issue One – applicability of the authorities in relation to statutory construction
- Conclusion
- “15 In the task of ascertaining whether a particular statutory provision imposes a charge, or grants an exemption from a charge, the Ramsay approach is generally described – as it is in the statements
- Issue Two – the scope of the rule prohibiting assignment “in gross”
- Conclusion
- Issue Three – ownership of the Businesses following the execution of the Agreements
- Conclusion
- No provision in the Agreements for the transfer of the Businesses
- No provision in the Agreements for the transfer of assets other than Goodwill or the assumption of any liabilities
- No transfer of employees
- Did BBUK carry on the Businesses after the Agreements became effective?
- This meant that the only way that BBUK could carry on the Businesses was through CPW as its agent. In that regard, I do not doubt the fact that it is possible for a company to carry on a business thro
- Entitlement to the profits of the Businesses
- Conclusion in relation to the ability to dictate the overall strategy and direction of the Businesses and entitlement to the profits of the Businesses
- Final observations
- Conclusion
- Issue Four – assignment in equity
- Conclusion
- Issue Five – not the same asset
- Conclusion
- Issue Six – the relevance of the transaction effected by Agreements in the event that Section 179(3) applied
- Conclusion
- Issue Seven – the tax consequences of the transaction effected by Agreements in the event that Section 179(3) applied
- Conclusions
![TC09562 - [2025] UKFTT 00762 (TC)](https://backend.juristeca.com/files/emisores/logo_7HSuEAV.png)